Trump Says He May Meet Kim in China. No Meeting Is Arranged

Donald Trump and Kim Jong Un walk side by side across the demarcation line at Panmunjom in the Korean Demilitarized Zone
Donald Trump and Kim Jong Un at the demarcation line in the Korean Demilitarized Zone on June 30, 2019 (file image). Photo: The White House via Wikimedia Commons, public domain

President Donald Trump said on Monday that he may meet Kim Jong Un while he is in China this week. “We may meet with Kim Jong-un also, so that’ll be good,” he told reporters on the South Lawn, the Korea Times reported. “We have a chance to accomplish a lot.” He added: “He may come; I don’t know. That’s up to (Chinese) President Xi (Jinping).”

That is the whole of it. No invitation has surfaced. No North Korean has said anything about attending. US officials say nothing is under way. Seven years after the last Trump-Kim handshake, one sentence on a lawn is all there is.

Washington’s own officials say there are no plans

A senior US official went further on Sunday. There are “no plans at all for engagement with North Korea,” the official said, per the Korea Times. The White House did not answer Yonhap’s question about North Korea. That question concerned Trump’s trilateral meeting with Xi Jinping and Vladimir Putin.

Seoul was no warmer. An official at the presidential office said North Korea is unlikely to attend a multilateral gathering. The foreign ministry said on Tuesday that it cannot predict whether a US-North Korea meeting will happen. Another official put the chance as “generally low.” The unification ministry said it has “no information” about Kim travelling to China.

Lim Eul-chul of Kyungnam University was blunter: “there are no signs of such preparations now.” Summits of this kind usually leave a trail of advance teams, security surveys and logistics flights. None has been reported.

Pyongyang named its price two weeks ago

Kim Yo Jong, the North Korean leader’s sister, set out the position on Nov. 4. Her statement went out through the state news agency KCNA. “The choice for peace includes dialogue of course, but this is not surely equated with national interests for us,” she said, per Yonhap via the Korea Times.

She said North Korea has no need to meet “such unreliable and hostile persons” face to face. They will not drop their confrontational policy, she said. Washington dropping what Pyongyang calls its hostile policy is, in her words, “a major premise and key to solving all problems.”

Her trigger was the FBI’s conclusion that North Korea stole more than $6 billion in cryptocurrency from Binance. She rejected the finding and called it a “grave political provocation.” She cited a South Korea-US-Japan ministerial that restated the goal of complete denuclearisation. She cited joint military drills too.

That is not a refusal to ever meet. It is a price, and so far nobody has paid it.

Distance is the weakest argument against a meeting

One common objection is geography. Shenzhen sits on China’s southern coast, more than 1,000 miles from the North Korean border. That makes a drop-in look improbable.

We measured it. Shenzhen is about 2,144 km from Pyongyang in a straight line, roughly 1,332 miles. Hanoi, where Kim went in February 2019, is about 2,761 km away. He covered most of that by armoured train over two and a half days. Singapore, where he flew in June 2018 on a borrowed Air China jet, is about 4,746 km from Pyongyang.

So Kim has twice travelled farther than Shenzhen to see Trump. The obstacle is not the map. It is that he has already said what he wants in return, and that nobody has started the work a summit needs.

The last three meetings produced one page and no deal

Trump met Kim three times, and the record of what came out is short. The Singapore summit on June 12, 2018 ended with a joint statement. Its text runs to four points. The two countries committed to new relations and to a “lasting and stable peace regime on the Korean Peninsula.” The North committed to work towards complete denuclearisation, and both sides to recover war dead.

Hanoi, on Feb. 27 and 28, 2019, broke up with no agreement. The two sides could not settle how much sanctions relief North Korea would get, and for dismantling what. On June 30, 2019, Trump stepped across the line at Panmunjom. He became the first sitting US president to set foot in North Korea. Working-level talks stalled soon after and have not restarted.

Park Won-gon of Ewha Womans University said Kim may now want working-level talks first, precisely to avoid a second Hanoi. “I think there is a possibility, but not in the immediate future,” he said.

Seoul is watching the terms, not the photograph

South Korean analysts are less worried about a meeting happening than about what it might trade away. Park warned that a deal could hand Pyongyang arms control or sanctions relief. It could also leave the short-range missiles aimed at Seoul untouched. Whang Taehee of Yonsei University said recognising North Korea as a nuclear state would “put South Korea at a significant disadvantage.”

Lim raised a practical limit. Any agreement with treaty force needs Congress. The Congress that would handle it changes on Jan. 3, 2027. The midterms gave Democrats both chambers. Trump is also negotiating from a weaker position at home, with his approval rating at 32% in two recent polls.

Reuters reported that analysts see the odds rising a little. The reason is the Kremlin, which has said a Kim-Putin meeting is possible. That would put Kim in the same city as Trump.

Thursday is the date that already exists

One meeting is actually on the calendar: Trump, Xi and Putin in Shenzhen on Thursday, Nov. 19. China’s foreign ministry calls it a gathering of “groundbreaking significance.” The White House says Trump will raise cutting nuclear arsenals. US officials told ABC News he does not plan to take up the war in Ukraine. That runs on the US-mediated track that went through Abu Dhabi this month.

If Kim turns up, the first sign will be an Air China jet on the Pyongyang-Shenzhen route. The second will be a North Korean advance team in the city. Until then, Trump has opened a door that Pyongyang has not walked through since 2019.

Exit mobile version