Saudi Arabia: 54-year-old retired teacher sentenced to death for his tweets

Saudi Arabia: 54-year-old retired teacher sentenced to death for his tweets

Human Rights Watch reported that a Saudi court sentenced a man to death based entirely on his Twitter and YouTube activity. The decision should be overturned because it represents an increase in the Saudi government’s crackdown on free expression and peaceful political opposition in the kingdom. On July 10, 2023, Saudi Arabia’s counterterrorism tribunal, the Specialized Criminal Court, convicted Muhammad al-Ghamdi, 54, a retired Saudi teacher, of many criminal charges relating exclusively to his peaceful expression online. The court sentenced him to death based on evidence from his tweets, retweets, and YouTube activities. The tweets in question are said to be about supporting Salman al-Awda, a political prisoner, and criticism of the Saudi royal family.

“Repression in Saudi Arabia has reached a terrifying new stage when a court can hand down the death penalty for nothing more than peaceful tweets”

“Repression in Saudi Arabia has reached a terrifying new stage when a court can hand down the death penalty for nothing more than peaceful tweets,” said Joey Shea, Saudi Arabia researcher at Human Rights Watch. “Saudi authorities have escalated their campaign against all dissent to mind-boggling levels and should reject this travesty of justice.” Saudi security forces arrested al-Ghamdi in front of his wife and children on June 11, 2022, outside his home in Mecca’s al-Nawwariyyah area, according to persons familiar with the matter. He was sent to al-Dhahban Prison, north of Jeddah, and detained in solitary confinement for four months. During this time, his family was unable to reach him, and he did not have access to a lawyer. The authorities eventually sent al-Ghamdi to Riyadh’s al-Ha’ir Prison.

Saudi interrogators questioned him about his tweets and political ideas, as well as his thoughts on others imprisoned for exercising their right to free expression. Al-Ghamdi did not have a lawyer for nearly a year, and once he did, he could only speak with the lawyer right before court appearances. Al-Ghamdi’s brother, Saeed bin Nasser al-Ghamdi, is a well-known Saudi Islamic scholar and government critic living in exile in the United Kingdom. In a tweet on August 24, Saeed wrote that the “false ruling aims to spite me personally after failed attempts by the investigations to return me to the country.” Saudi authorities in recent years have increasingly retaliated against the family members of critics and dissidents abroad in an effort to coerce them to return to the country, Human Rights Watch said.

Court documents Human Rights Watch reviewed show that the Specialized Criminal Court sentenced al-Ghamdi to death on July 10 under article 30 of Saudi Arabia’s counterterrorism law for “describing the King or the Crown Prince in a way that undermines religion or justice,” article 34 for “supporting a terrorist ideology,” article 43 for “communication with a terrorist entity,” and article 44 for publishing false news “with the intention of executing a terrorist crime.” Al-Ghamdi’s trial judgment states that he used his accounts on the X, formally Twitter, platform, and YouTube to commit his “crimes.”

The public prosecutor sought the maximum penalties for all charges against al-Ghamdi. The documents say that the court issued the sentence on the grounds that the crimes “targeted the status of the King and the Crown Prince,” and that the “magnitude of his actions is amplified by the fact they occurred through a global media platform, necessitating a strict punishment.”

According to the records, al-Ghamdi has two X platform accounts

According to the records, al-Ghamdi has two X platform accounts. According to Human Rights Watch, the first account had two followers while the second had eight. Both accounts, which have fewer than 1,000 tweets altogether, primarily included retweets of well-known Saudi regime critics. Several tweets criticizing the Saudi royal family are cited as evidence, as is at least one calling for the release of Salman al-Awda, a prominent cleric facing a possible death sentence on various vague charges related to his political statements, associations, and positions, as well as other prominent imprisoned Islamic scholars.

According to individuals familiar with the matter, Al-Ghamdi does not consider himself a political or human rights activist. He says that he is a private person who only expressed worries about the Saudi government’s handling of the X platform, according to them. According to the sources, Al-Ghamdi has a number of major mental health concerns, and Saudi officials have refused to provide him with some of the prescription medications he requires to treat and manage his conditions. (Clonazepam) According to them, Al-Ghamdi’s mental and physical condition has deteriorated significantly since his arrest.

Al-Ghamdi’s death sentence is the most recent and harshest in a string of incidents in which Saudi authorities have targeted peaceful online expression on social media. Over the last year, Saudi courts have convicted and sentenced social media users who have criticized the regime to decades in prison. In August 2022, a Saudi appeals court enhanced the prison sentence of Salma al Shehab, a Saudi PhD student, from 6 to 34 years based solely on her behavior on the X platform. On appeal, the sentence was reduced to 27 years. On the same day, another lady, Nourah bin Saeed al-Qahtani, was sentenced to 45 years in prison for “using the internet to tear the [country’s] social fabric.”

Human Rights Watch has documented widespread and persistent abuses in Saudi Arabia’s criminal justice system

Despite the leadership’s promises to reduce the use of the death sentence, Saudi authorities hanged 81 men on March 12, 2022, the country’s largest mass execution in years. According to Saudi activists, 41 of the men belonged to the country’s Shia Muslim minority, which has long faced systematic persecution from the government. Human Rights Watch has documented widespread and persistent abuses in Saudi Arabia’s criminal justice system, making it nearly impossible for defendants like al-Ghamdi to receive a fair trial.

Human Rights Watch has consistently condemned widespread abuses in Saudi Arabia’s criminal justice system, including long periods of incarceration without charge or trial, denial of legal representation, and courts’ reliance on torture-tainted confessions as the sole basis of conviction. The abuses of defendants’ rights are so fundamental and widespread that reconciling Saudi Arabia’s criminal justice system with a system founded on the fundamental principles of the rule of law and international human rights norms is difficult.

International human rights norms, particularly the Arab Charter on Human Rights, which Saudi Arabia ratified, require governments that utilize the death sentence to use it only for the “most serious crimes,” and in rare situations. In November 2022, the Office of the United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights issued a statement on Saudi Arabia’s alarming number of executions after the country overturned a 21-month unofficial moratorium on the use of the death penalty for drug-related offenses. Human Rights Watch opposes the death penalty in all countries and situations. Capital punishment is unparalleled in its harshness and finality, yet it is invariably and universally marred by arbitrariness, prejudice, and error.

“Saudi authorities are now resorting to online criticism not only with unfair show trials but with the threat of capital punishment,” Shea said. “It’s difficult to see how the Saudi leadership’s pledges to become a more rights-respecting society are meaningful when a mere critical tweet can lead to a death sentence.”

Exit mobile version